12 Best Baseball Glove Oils of 2019: Break In Your Gloves

As baseball seasons ramp up all over the country, players young and old are digging out their old gloves or purchasing new ones to get ready for the season. Baseball gloves, like most sports’ equipment needs proper care and maintenance to function the way it was designed. This is even more true for real leather gloves that tend to grow stiff from the sun or inactivity. This can affect catching ability which can mean the difference between an out or a home run – for the other team. So, to keep gloves in the tip top shape, or to break in new ones, it is important to have the proper conditioning oil to keep the leather smooth and malleable and to keep the balls in your glove.

There are a lot of leather oils out there, but it is important to understand the differences and find the one that is right for you. If you have a brand-new glove, you might want a different product than a player trying to preserve his father’s twenty year old glove. Some oils work well for breaking in and preserving, but others are designed with one in mind. Figuring out exactly what you need can be trickier, so read on to learn about the best glove oils on the market and find the one that is perfect for you.

Top Baseball Glove Oils Comparison Chart

NameNet Wt.PriceWhere to Buy?
Wilson Premium Glove Oil4 oz. $Check Price on Amazon
Nokona NLT Classic Leather Conditioner4 oz. $$Check Price on Amazon
Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner2.11 oz.$Check Price on Amazon
Rawlings Gold Glove Butter2 oz.$Check Price on Amazon
Baseball/Softball Conditioning Oil from Rawlings4 oz.$$$Check Price on Amazon
Fiebings Mink Oil Paste6 oz.$Check Price on Amazon
Sarna Baseball Glove Conditioner8 oz.$$$Check Price on Amazon
Pecard Baseball Glove Conditioner2.5 oz.$Check Price on Amazon
Hot Glove Management Kit2 oz.$Check Price on Amazon
Easton Glove Oil91 g$Check Price on Amazon
LLB Baseball Glove Conditioner4 oz. $Check Price on Amazon
Rawlings Glovolium XL Trigger Spray8 oz. $$Check Price on Amazon

Baseball Glove Oils Buying Guide

What should you look for in a glove oil?

There are glove oils and glove conditioners. Both are similar and many times one is used for both purposes, but they do have difference functions. Leather conditioner is used to help preserve or maintain already broken in leather. This is for older gloves that just need a loosen up before the season or a big game. Oils, on the other hand, help to break in new gloves so they are not firm. Many oils on this list do both, but it’s a small distinction that can matter when you are looking for the perfect product.

Another important factor to consider is whether you want a thick balm that you have to really rub into the leather, or if you want an easy to spray applicator. Some people prefer the old fashion balm type of conditioners that require more work up front, but many claim is does a better job at maintaining softness over time. Other people want to spray and go, looking for convenience and ease, without worrying as much about the long-term benefits. The spray bottles are definitely more convenient for travel and keeping in your bag at all times, but this really depends on your preferences.

Some other factors to consider when buying in oil is if and how much it may discolor the leather. If the color of your leather is very important to you, finding an oil that won’t affect it may be your best option. On the other hand, some of the best oils on this list are notorious for altering the color, so if the discoloration doesn’t bother you, it might be worth considering.

Finally, price and bottle size are two things to consider when shopping for the perfect glove oil. A product that works well is something you’ll want to invest in, so while cheap products might work well for you, the more expensive ones are necessarily worth discounting too quickly. Some of the options come with a cloth or other supplies, which is something to keep in mind when considering the price.

With those things in mind, take a look at the list below and you’ll be able to determine the best baseball glove oil for you and your glove.

Best Baseball Glove Oils Reviews

1. Wilson Premium Glove Oil

The Wilson premium glove oil is an all-around great choice for baseball and catcher’s gloves. Not only is it cheaper than many of the other options on the market, but it also is one of the top rated products by consumers. It is a light-weight oil that will not let the glove absorb too much of the oil or cause any significant discoloration.

It also comes in a convenient spray applicator bottle to make applying to gloves a simple and painless process. Spray where you want without worrying about over-oiling your mitt. It can be used for old leather or new leather and won’t discolor as much as other oils.

Overall, if you want bang for your buck, this is the best option out there. It will oil your glove perfectly at half the cost of others and work well with breaking in as well as maintaining gloves.

Pros:

  • Cheap
  • Spray applicator
  • For both old and new leathers

Cons:

  • Small container
  • Still need to dab with a cloth

2. Nokona NLT Classic Leather Conditioner

The Nokona Conditioner is a brand that is used and trusted by players young and old, alike. It is easy to see why with this proven oiling formula that not only is great for breaking in brand new or stiff gloves, but is also great for maintaining shape throughout the years.

With this mighty little tube, less is more and even a small amount can have huge, lasting effects on baseball mitts. With many players coming back to this product for well over thirty years, it is easy to see why it ranked so high on our list.

This product is consistently good and can be used to condition, but also to clean gloves when and if they become too slippery and smooth. It will not weigh down your glove or leave behind any sort of greasy feel. There is a chance it might discolor your glove slightly, but compared to other products it will not have a huge effect on it.

Overall, the Nokona conditioner is a stellar product at a super affordable price.

Pros:

  • A very trusted brand
  • A small amount makes a big difference
  • Cleans as well as maintains

Cons:

  • No spray applicator
  • Small size
  • May cause some discoloration

3. Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner

The Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner is a handy oil that can be used to do tune-ups on stiff gloves. This easy to use oil is made in the USA and can be used on new and old gloves alike. Use it on stiff older gloves that need a tune-up or brand new gloves that need to be broken in. A small amount goes a long way and can have your glove significantly soften in no time.

This conditioner is not as thorough as some of the other oils and it won’t completely undo all the damage done over the years, but it can definitely help restore some softness to baseball gloves. To note, it will darken the leather up, so if your leather is a particular shade, it may not be the best glove oil for you.

Unlike other conditioners, this one comes in a jar, instead of a tube which makes it more prone to messes. Overall, it is a great product to soften mitts, but won’t work any miracles on super damaged gloves. For the price, you are not getting as much as some other products, but it still a good conditioner to use on old and new gloves.

Pros:

  • Made in the USA
  • Nice smell
  • Works on old and new gloves

Cons:

  • Can Darken the leather
  • Won’t undo all damage
  • Comes in jar

4. Rawlings Gold Glove Butter

The Rawlings Gold Glove Butter provides immediate aid to tight or stiff gloves. This butter comes in a thicker balm than many other oils and as a result can be caked into the laces more easily. It feels grittier than some other oils and to avoid the caking you really have to rub it in. However, it does not discolor the leather as much as some of the other products.

This butter is great for immediate use when you just want to quickly loosen up a glove. It is not as efficient or effective as other oils but will provide a temporary fix when needed. It can be used for new gloves as well as older gloves that need a tune-up.

Overall, it won’t work any miracles and is not intended to be a long-term fix for stiff gloves, but for the price it is a good option to have on hand if you find yourself with a stiff new glove or an old glove in need of a quick tune-up.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • No discoloration
  • Don’t need to use much to get the job done

Cons:

  • Gritty
  • Not a good smell
  • Not a long term solution

5. Baseball/Softball Conditioning Oil from Rawlings

This specialized Rawlings formula is designed for both breaking in a new glove and preserving an old one. It’s easy to spray applicator and included red microfiber cloth make it simple to loosen up stiff fingers or palms for better playing.

It is a light weight oil that will not darken the leather or leave a greasy film behind like some other products. One application of this oil should cause a significant difference in the glove and using it repeatedly should help preserve gloves for a long time.

This is a solid oil to use for all types of gloves, but it is more expensive than some of the other oils on the market.

Pros:

  • Won’t darken leather
  • Spray applicator
  • Cloth included

Cons:

  • Pricey
  • Basic oil

6. Fiebings Mink Oil Paste

Fiebings mink oil paste is a classic glove conditioner that has been trusted for generations. It comes in a thicker paste than many of the spray on oils, but works well to soften old leather and keep gloves working the way they should.

It is an all-natural product that is thick to apply, but will make your glove soft and malleable. The downside is that is will definitely make the leather significantly darker and might leave a greasy feeling on the product.

Overall, it’s a great leather product that has been trusted for years. It’s on the cheaper side, but isn’t necessarily designed specifically for baseball gloves, but for all leather products in general.

Pros:

  • All natural
  • Very well trusted
  • Inexpensive

Cons:

  • Darkens leather
  • Greasier than others
  • Not specially designed for gloves

7. Sarna Baseball Glove Conditioner

The Sarna Baseball Glove conditioner is a great product for leather gloves as well as other leather products. This conditioner is great for ball players that play lots of games and need to keep their gloves in tip-top shape. It dries quickly, without leaving a film or and discoloration behind.

It isn’t as useful at breaking in newer gloves as other options, but it is a great choice to keep older gloves in play ready shape. It is significantly pricier than other options, but a solid conditioner for players that constantly want to keep their gloves from drying out in the Spring and Summer heat.

Pros:

  • Great for constant conditioning
  • Made in the USA
  • Won’t discolor glove

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Won’t break in new gloves
  • Glass bottle more easily broken

8. Pecard Baseball Glove Conditioner

The Pecard Baseball glove conditioner is a thick balm that is great for breaking in, maintaining, and preserving baseball gloves – new and old alike. It is a trusted brand that has been around for more than one hundred years and is made in the USA.

It goes on thick and can be harder to spread around than other oils, but won’t leave any residue or film behind once it’s wiped in. And unlike some oils that may need to be applied several times to work, this conditioner will soften your glove quickly and easily without the need for reapplication.

It’s a mid-range product that will definitely get the job done. If you are willing to a pay a bit more and like the thicker balm that won’t discolor leather and is a trusted name, this product might just be for you.

Pros:

  • Trusted and well-established brand
  • One application will get the job done
  • Made in the US

Cons:

  • More expensive
  • Harder to rub in
  • Thick balm

9. Hot Glove Management Kit

The Hot Glove Management kit is an affordable, all-in-one kit that comes with glove oil, glove conditioner and a brush. While oils and conditioners are similar and many people only use one or the other, having both on hand is a nice addition to your glove management.

This kit is lower priced than several other items on the list and because it comes with more than just oil, it is a great value for your money. This system does involve baking, which some gloves don’t recommend, so it may not be the best option for everyone.

Overall, it is a good kit for the price, but it might not work as well as expected for some gloves.

Pros:

  • Cheap
  • All-in-one
  • Comes with a brush

Cons:

  • Involves baking for breaking in
  • Might make it stiffer
  • Leaves a film behind

10. Easton Glove Oil

Easton glove oil is a no frills product designed to help break in and maintain glove softness. Unlike other oils it is unscented and clear, much like baby oil, which can be a big benefit if you are sensitive to smells that might linger on your glove. The clearness is also great because it won’t alter the color of your glove in any way.

It isn’t anything revolutionary and won’t do quite as well as other oils at breaking in a new glove, but it will help maintain older gloves for longer and help preserve their shape. For the price and the size of the bottle, it isn’t the best option out there, but will help keep older gloves useable for longer.

Pros:

  • Clear
  • Odorless
  • No frills product

Cons:

  • No spray applicator
  • Won’t break in newer gloves
  • Less value for money

11. LLB Baseball Glove Conditioner

 The LLB Baseball glove conditioner is made from neatsfoot oil and comes in an easy to use 4-ounce squirt bottle for convenient application to gloves. It is a great product for conditioning and preserving older leather but isn’t a great product for breaking in new gloves.

This oil is super easy to apply and without using much you can soften your glove significantly. It also won’t cause as much discoloration as other products but might leave a film or greasy feeling behind. At one of the cheapest options, its great for budget ball players that still wish to preserve their gloves, but isn’t nearly as great as many of the other oils.

Pros:

  • Least Expensive
  • Don’t need much
  • No discoloration

Cons:

  • Leaves behind film
  • Isn’t as useful at breaking in new gloves
  • Small bottle

12. Rawlings Glovolium XL Trigger Spray

The Rawlings Glovolium is a simple spray on conditioner that helps soften old gloves. It’s easy to use pump applicator makes hard to reach spots simple to clean and maintain. A simple lanolin formula, this oil works to smooth even the stiffest glove.

It’s not a spray pump applicator like other products, but the thumb pump still helps you get into those hard to reach nooks and crannies on a baseball glove. It really helps to maintain the glove, but if you are working with an older glove that might be more stiff and cracked, this product might need to be reapplied several times in order to see an improvement.

Overall, this product will serve you will and does the job it’s meant to do, but because it might require multiple applications in order to see a clear difference, it’s not the best option out there. And because it is not necessarily the cheapest option, there are products that are better value for you money.

Pros:

  • Easy to apply
  • Priced well
  • Maintains gloves

Cons:

  • Bottle doesn’t last long
  • Thumb pump not spray pump
  • Might take several applications

Conclusion And Final Baseball Glove Oils Recommendations

Many glove oils and conditioners are very similar in nature, but the little differences can really impact your decision. Finding a trustworthy glove oil that will help keep your baseball mitt in pristine shape can determine how you play for the season and seasons to come.

If you are looking for the most bang for your buck, the Wilson Premium Glove oil is all around the best product. Not only is it one of the most affordable options, but it also won’t discolor your glove and leaves them soft and ready to play. It is also one of the most convenient products with a handy spray applicator to guarantee you won’t use too much and leave your glove greasy.

If you are looking for the most established brand, Fieberg’s won’t let you down. This leather conditioning brand has been around for well over one hundred years and continues to be a top rated product. While Fieberg’s isn’t specifically designed with baseball mitts in mind, the mink oil is a trusted softener and will keep your glove malleable. The downside is that it will very much discolor your glove, so that is something to keep in mind if you choose Fieberg’s.

If you are looking for the best of both worlds, the Baseball Condition Oil by Rawlings will help break in brand new stiff gloves and keep older mitts in great condition. This is a nice mid-priced item that has hundreds of backed reviews and comes with a cleaning cloth for more convenience. It’s a nice light-weight oil that won’t leave grease and is easy to throw in your bag for travel.

Overall, you can’t go wrong with any of the products on this list. They were all designed to keep leather soft and malleable and keep you playing your best possible game.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *